Buying your first wig is exciting—it opens up a world of new styles, confidence, and self-expression.
But with so many options out there, it’s easy to make mistakes when buying a wig, especially if you’re unsure where to start.
Should you go for synthetic or human hair? What size do you need? How do you make sure it looks natural?
These are common questions first-time buyers ask, and getting the answers right can make all the difference.
The good news? You’re not alone. Many beginners fall into common wig buying mistakes, but with the right guidance, they’re completely avoidable.
At My Beautiful Wigs, we’ve helped countless customers find their perfect fit—whether they need a wig for fashion, convenience, or medical reasons.
We know that a little knowledge goes a long way in making sure your first wig-buying experience is a great one.
That’s exactly why we’ve put together this guide—to help you steer clear of wig shopping mistakes, avoid unnecessary expenses, and ensure you walk away with a wig that makes you look and feel fantastic.
Ready to get started?
Let’s dive into the biggest wig buying mistakes—and, more importantly, how to avoid them.
Mistake #1: Not Knowing Your Wig Size
One of the most common mistakes when buying a wig is choosing the wrong size.
A poorly fitted wig can feel uncomfortable, slip throughout the day, or worse—look unnatural.
If a wig is too tight, it can cause headaches and irritation, while a wig that’s too loose may shift or not sit securely on your head.
How to Avoid This Mistake
Before purchasing, take the time to measure your head correctly.
Wig sizes aren’t one-size-fits-all—there are petite, average, and large cap sizes, and knowing your exact measurements will help you get the most comfortable and natural fit.
Here’s a simple way to measure your head:
- 1. Use a flexible tape measure. Measure around your head, following your natural hairline (just above your ears and around the back of your head).
- 2. Note your circumference. Most wig brands provide a size chart—compare your measurement to find your perfect wig size.
- 3. Consider adjustable caps. Some wigs come with adjustable straps, allowing for small fit adjustments to improve comfort and security.
Wig Cap Sizes & Adjustments
Wig caps come in different constructions, each affecting how the wig fits and feels:
- Lace Front Wigs: Offer a natural-looking hairline with a snug fit.
- Full Lace Wigs: Provide full scalp coverage and greater flexibility for styling.
- Monofilament Wigs: Designed for a realistic scalp appearance and added comfort.
- Machine-Made Wigs: Often more structured with less stretch than hand-tied options.
PRO TIP:
- If you're unsure about your size, opt for a wig with adjustable straps or an elastic cap for a customisable fit. For a detailed wig size guide, check out our wig sizing chart here.
Mistake #2: Choosing the Wrong Wig Type for Your Needs
Common Misconception: “All wigs are the same.”
Many first-time buyers assume that a wig is just a wig—but in reality, there are different types of wigs, each with unique benefits.
Choosing the wrong type can lead to frustration, wasted money, and a wig that doesn’t suit your lifestyle.
Reality: Not All Wigs Are Created Equal
Wigs come in three main categories:
Different Wig Types
Synthetic Wigs:
Pre-styled, low-maintenance, and budget-friendly. Best for those who want a ready-to-wear look without daily styling.
Human Hair Wigs:
Highly natural-looking and fully customisable, but require more maintenance. Perfect for those who love to style their hair.
Blended Wigs (Human Hair + Synthetic):
Offer the best of both worlds—more realistic than synthetic but lower maintenance than 100% human hair.
AVOID:
- Many first-time buyers make the mistake of choosing a human hair wig when they really want a low-maintenance option—or going for a synthetic wig when they need styling flexibility.
How to Choose the Right Wig for Your Lifestyle
Not sure which type is right for you? Use this quick checklist to find your perfect match:
Choose a synthetic wig if:
Choose a human hair wig if:
Choose a blended wig if:
PRO-TIP:
- If you’re new to wigs, starting with a high-quality synthetic or blended wig can be a great way to ease into the experience before committing to human hair.
Need Help Choosing the Right Wig? Book a Consultation!
Still unsure whether a synthetic, human hair, or blended wig is right for you? Let us help!
At My Beautiful Wigs, our expert wig specialists are here to guide you through the process, ensuring you find a wig that suits your lifestyle, budget, and preferences.
Book a Consultation Today:
✔ FREE 30-Min Zoom Consultation (30 mins) – Perfect for online orders or remote assistance. £0.00 – Book Here
Click here to schedule your session and take the stress out of buying your first wig!
Mistake #3: Ignoring Wig Cap Construction
Why It Matters
When buying your first wig, it’s easy to focus solely on style and colour—but wig cap construction is just as important.
The cap is the foundation of your wig, affecting comfort, breathability, and how natural it looks when worn.
Choose the wrong type, and you might end up with a wig that feels itchy, too hot, or doesn’t blend seamlessly with your hairline.
Common Mistake: Choosing a Wig Based on Style Alone
Many first-time buyers assume all wigs feel the same underneath, but cap construction determines how secure, lightweight, and realistic your wig looks. For example, lace front wigs create a natural-looking hairline, while full lace wigs allow for versatile styling. Buying a wig without considering these differences can lead to discomfort and an unnatural appearance.
Understanding Wig Cap Types
Here’s a quick guide to the most common wig cap constructions:
Lace Front Wigs
One of the most popular options, lace front wigs feature a sheer lace panel at the front, creating a natural hairline. Ideal for people who want a realistic look with easy styling at the front.
Full Lace Wigs
Made entirely of lace, these wigs allow for maximum styling versatility. You can part your hair in any direction and even wear it in a ponytail. However, they require more maintenance.
Monofilament Wigs
Designed for a natural scalp appearance, these wigs have a fine mesh cap where individual hairs are hand-tied, creating the illusion of hair growing from your scalp. Perfect for those who prioritise realism and comfort.
Machine-Made Wigs
The most affordable and durable option, these wigs use sewn-in wefts and are great for those looking for fuller, voluminous styles. However, they lack the natural parting of lace and monofilament wigs.
Pro Tip:
- If you have a sensitive scalp, monofilament wigs or those with silk caps tend to be the most comfortable.
Where to Learn More
For an in-depth look at different wig cap constructions and their benefits, check out this expert guide on wig caps from the American Cancer Society.
Mistake #4: Not Considering Skin Tone When Choosing a Wig Colour
The Problem: A Wig That Looks Great in Photos Might Not Suit You in Real Life
One of the most common mistakes when buying a wig is choosing a colour based on how it looks in pictures—only to find out it doesn’t complement your skin tone once you try it on.
A wig that clashes with your natural undertones can make your complexion look dull or overly harsh, which is why understanding how to match your wig colour to your skin tone is essential.
How to Choose the Right Wig Colour for Your Skin Tone
The best way to find a flattering wig colour is to use the warm vs. cool undertone rule. Here’s how:
Step 1: Determine Your Undertone
Look at the veins on your wrist under natural light:
Not sure?
Hold a white piece of paper up to your face. If your skin looks rosy or pinkish, you’re cool-toned. If it looks more golden or yellow, you’re warm-toned.
Best Wig Colours for Your Undertone
- If You Have a Cool Undertone (Pink or Bluish Skin)
Avoid: Golden blonde, caramel, warm reds (These may make your skin look washed out.)
2. If You Have a Warm Undertone (Golden or Olive Skin)
Avoid: Platinum blonde, ash brown, cool black (These can make your complexion appear dull.)
3. If You Have a Neutral Undertone (Balanced Skin Tone)
Pro Tip:
- If you’re transitioning to wigs after hair loss, choosing a shade close to your natural hair colour can make the adjustment feel more comfortable.
Want More Guidance? Use Our Wig Colour Guide!
If you need help selecting the perfect wig colour for your skin tone, check out our Wig Colour Guide, where we break down the best shades for every complexion.
Mistake #5: Expecting Synthetic Wigs to Be Styled Like Human Hair
Reality Check: Not All Synthetic Wigs Can Handle Heat
One of the most common mistakes when buying a wig is assuming that synthetic wigs can be styled with curling irons, straighteners, or blow dryers—just like human hair.
While advancements in wig technology mean some heat-resistant synthetic wigs exist, standard synthetic wigs will melt, frizz, or become permanently damaged if exposed to high temperatures.
Common Pitfall: The Curling Iron Catastrophe
Many first-time wig buyers have learned this lesson the hard way.
They excitedly grab their curling wand, apply heat to a synthetic wig, and… disaster strikes. The fibres melt together, leaving a tangled mess that can’t be fixed.
Unlike human hair wigs, which can be heat-styled and re-styled, most synthetic wigs are designed to hold their shape and style permanently.
Pro Tip:
- If you want a curly or straight style in a synthetic wig, it’s best to buy one pre-styled in that texture rather than trying to change it yourself.
Solution: If You Want Styling Flexibility, Choose Heat-Resistant Synthetic Wigs
If styling is important to you but you still prefer synthetic wigs for their affordability and low maintenance, look for heat-friendly or heat-resistant synthetic wigs.
These wigs are made from special fibres that can withstand low to medium heat settings (usually up to 130–150°C).
How to Safely Style a Heat-Resistant Synthetic Wig:
Alternative Tip:
- For non-heat-friendly synthetic wigs, try steam styling or using rollers on damp hair to achieve a gentle curl or wave.
Would You Like More Styling Flexibility?
Browse our collection of heat-friendly wigs here or book a consultation for expert guidance.
Mistake #6: Choosing the Cheapest Option Without Research
The Risk: A Bargain Wig Might Not Be a Bargain After All
Everyone loves a good deal, but when it comes to buying your first wig, cheaper isn’t always better.
While budget-friendly options exist, low-quality wigs often look unnatural, shed excessively, and don’t last—meaning you could end up replacing them far sooner than expected.
Many first-time buyers make the mistake of purchasing wigs from unverified online marketplaces that use heavily edited product images.
What arrives in the post can be far from what was advertised—thin, stiff, overly shiny, or completely the wrong colour.
Worse still, some cheap wigs tangle easily and can’t be restyled, leaving you frustrated and out of pocket.
PRO Tip:
- A high-quality synthetic wig can look far more realistic than a poor-quality human hair wig—so focus on quality, not just price.
How to Avoid This Mistake: Invest in Quality & Do Your Research
When choosing a wig, it’s important to balance affordability with quality.
That doesn’t mean you have to spend a fortune, but it does mean doing a little research to make sure you’re getting a well-made wig from a trusted seller.
Check Customer Reviews – Before purchasing, look for real customer reviews with photos to ensure the wig looks and performs as expected.
Research the Brand – Stick to reputable wig retailers rather than buying from unverified sellers with no return policies.
Look at the Fibre Quality – Good synthetic wigs should mimic the movement and texture of natural hair, while human hair wigs should be soft and not overly processed.
Beware of Deals That Seem Too Good to Be True – If a 100% human hair wig is selling for the price of a synthetic, it's probably not genuine.
ALTERNATIVE TIP:
- If you’re shopping on a budget, consider blended wigs (human + synthetic hair)—they offer a natural look with a lower price tag than full human hair wigs.
Shop High-Quality Wigs You Can Trust
At My Beautiful Wigs, we believe that everyone deserves a wig that makes them feel confident—without worrying about poor quality. That’s why we stock only premium synthetic, blended, and human hair wigs that are designed to look and feel natural.
Explore Our High-Quality Wig Collection Here: Shop Wigs Now
Mistake #7: Not Learning How to Care for a Wig
Why It’s a Mistake: Wigs Require Proper Maintenance to Last
Buying a wig is an investment—whether it’s synthetic, human hair, or a blend, proper care is essential to keep it looking natural and lasting as long as possible.
Unfortunately, many first-time wig buyers overwash, underwash, or use the wrong products, which can lead to dryness, tangling, shedding, and an overall shorter lifespan.
A well-maintained wig can last months or even years, while a neglected one can lose its shape, texture, and softness in just a few weeks.
PRO TIP:
- The way you care for your wig should depend on the wig type—synthetic wigs need a different routine than human hair wigs.
How to Properly Care for Your Wig
Follow these simple steps to keep your wig looking fresh and beautiful for longer:
Washing & Conditioning
Never wring or rub your wig when washing—gently swish it in cool water and pat it dry with a towel.
Drying & Styling
Avoid brushing wet wigs—this can cause unnecessary shedding and stretching of the cap.
Proper Storage
If travelling, store your wig in a silk bag or a travel wig box to keep it safe.
Need a Full Step-by-Step Guide?
For more detailed care instructions, check out our Complete Wig Care Guide to learn how to wash, condition, and style your wig the right way.
Mistake #8: Not Securing the Wig Properly
The Problem: A Loose Wig Can Shift or Fall Off
One of the biggest concerns for first-time wig buyers is the fear of their wig slipping or moving throughout the day.
A poorly secured wig can cause discomfort, affect confidence, and, in some cases, even come off unexpectedly.
Whether you’re wearing a lace front wig, a full wig, or a partial hairpiece, ensuring a secure and comfortable fit is essential.
Real Customer Insight:
- Many new wig wearers express worries about their wig moving while talking, exercising, or even in windy conditions. But with the right wig security solutions, you can wear your wig with total confidence.
How to Keep Your Wig Secure and Comfortable
There are several ways to secure your wig properly, depending on your preference and lifestyle:
PRO-TIP:
- If you have a sensitive scalp, opt for a velvet wig grip or a hypoallergenic wig tape for a secure yet comfortable fit.
What Our Customers Say About Securing Wigs
"I was so nervous about my wig slipping, but using a wig grip changed everything! It’s comfortable and keeps my wig in place all day." – Emma, My Beautiful Wigs Customer
"I work out regularly, and wig tape has been a game-changer! No more worrying about my wig shifting while exercising." – Jasmine, My Beautiful Wigs Customer
Need Help Finding the Best Wig Security Solution?
Mistake #9: Overlooking the Importance of Natural Hair Preparation
Why It’s Important: Your Natural Hair Affects Wig Fit and Comfort
When buying your first wig, it’s easy to focus on choosing the perfect style, colour, and cap type—while completely forgetting about what’s underneath.
But how you prepare your natural hair before wearing a wig plays a huge role in how comfortable, natural, and secure your wig feels.
If your hair isn’t prepped correctly, you might find that your wig sits too high, feels lumpy, or doesn’t fit securely.
Proper hair preparation ensures that your wig lays smoothly and naturally, giving you a flawless look.
Pro Tip:
- Even if you have very short hair or hair loss, a wig cap can improve comfort and help keep your wig in place.
How to Prepare Your Natural Hair for a Wig
For Short Hair:
For Medium to Long Hair:
For People With Hair Loss or Sensitive Scalps:
Avoid Bulky Styles Underneath:
Want a Perfect Wig Fit? Get Expert Advice!
Mistake #10: Not Seeking Expert Advice Before Buying
The Final Pitfall: Buying a Wig Without Professional Guidance
With so many wigs available online, it’s tempting to click ‘buy now’ without speaking to an expert—but this is one of the biggest wig buying mistakes you can make.
Without professional guidance, you risk choosing the wrong size, cap type, hair fibre, or colour—all of which can leave you feeling disappointed with your purchase.
Wigs aren’t just about looks—they need to be comfortable, secure, and suited to your lifestyle.
Pro Tip:
- A short consultation with a wig expert can save you time, money, and frustration by ensuring you pick the best wig for your needs from the start.
Why Expert Advice Makes a Difference
Real Customer Story:
- “I spent hours researching wigs online, but I was still unsure which one would suit me. After a quick consultation, I found the perfect wig in minutes! It fit perfectly and looked so natural.” – Sophia, My Beautiful Wigs Customer
Book Your Free Wig Consultation Today
Click here to schedule your session and get expert guidance before you buy!
Book a Consultation:
✔ In-Person Wig Consultation (90 mins) – Get expert advice in our private salon. £50.00 – Book Here
✔ FREE 30-Min Zoom Consultation – Perfect for online orders or remote assistance. £0.00 – Book Here
Conclusion: Avoid These Mistakes & Find Your Perfect Wig
Buying your first wig is an exciting journey, and like anything new, it comes with a learning curve.
But now that you know the top mistakes to avoid when buying a wig, you’re ahead of the game!
By understanding wig sizes, cap types, hair preparation, and proper care, you’re already on the path to finding a wig that looks and feels amazing.
No more guesswork, no more frustration—just confidence in your choice.
What’s Next? Take the Next Step with Confidence
Now that you’re equipped with all the right knowledge, it’s time to find the perfect wig for you!
Your perfect wig is waiting—let’s find it together!
1. How do I choose the right wig size?
Selecting the correct wig size is crucial for comfort and a natural appearance. To determine your size:
- Measure Your Head Circumference: Use a flexible tape measure to wrap around your head, starting at your front hairline, moving just above your ears, and around the nape of your neck.
- Consult Size Charts: Compare your measurements to the wig manufacturer's sizing chart, as sizes can vary between brands.
For a detailed guide, refer to our Wig Size Guide.
2. What's the difference between synthetic and human hair wigs?
The primary differences include:
- Synthetic Wigs: Generally more affordable, low-maintenance, and come pre-styled. However, they may lack the natural look and feel of human hair and often cannot be heat-styled unless specified as heat-resistant.
- Human Hair Wigs: Offer a natural appearance and can be styled like your own hair but require more upkeep and are typically more expensive.
Consider your lifestyle and preferences when choosing between the two.
3. How can I make my wig look natural?
To achieve a natural look:
- Select the Right Cap Construction: Opt for lace front or monofilament caps that mimic a natural hairline and part.
- Match Your Skin Tone: Choose a wig color that complements your complexion.
- Proper Application: Secure the wig correctly and consider trimming or styling it to frame your face.
For personalized advice, book a consultation with our wig specialists.
4. How often should I wash my wig?
Washing frequency depends on the wig type and usage:
- Synthetic Wigs: Every 8–10 wears.
- Human Hair Wigs: Every 6–8 wears.
Always use products specifically designed for wigs to maintain their quality.
5. Can I style my synthetic wig with heat tools?
Most synthetic wigs are not heat-friendly and can be damaged by styling tools. However, some are made with heat-resistant fibers:
- Standard Synthetic Wigs: Avoid heat styling.
- Heat-Resistant Synthetic Wigs: Can be styled with tools on low to medium settings (up to 130–150°C).
Always check the manufacturer's guidelines before applying heat.
6. How do I secure my wig to prevent it from slipping?
To keep your wig in place:
- Use Wig Grips or Caps: These provide friction to hold the wig securely.
- Adjustable Straps: Many wigs come with built-in straps for a customized fit.
- Wig Tape or Adhesive: Offers additional security, especially for lace front wigs.
For more tips, refer to our Wig Security Guide.
7. What should I do if my wig doesn't fit properly?
If your wig feels too tight or loose:
- Adjust the Straps: Most wigs have adjustable straps to modify the fit.
- Wear a Wig Cap: It can help secure the wig and provide a better fit.
- Consult a Professional: They can offer resizing options or suggest a different cap size.
For assistance, book a free consultation with our experts.
8. How can I prevent my wig from tangling?
To minimize tangling:
- Regular Gentle Brushing: Use a wide-tooth comb or wig brush, starting from the ends and working upward.
- Proper Storage: Store your wig on a stand away from direct sunlight.
- Use Recommended Products: Apply detangling sprays designed for wigs.
For comprehensive care tips, see our Wig Maintenance Guide.
9. Is it normal for wigs to shed?
Some shedding is normal, especially with new wigs. However, excessive shedding can result from:
- Over-Brushing: Be gentle to avoid pulling out fibers.
- Improper Washing: Follow recommended techniques and use appropriate products.
If shedding persists, consult with a wig specialist.
10. Can I sleep or shower with my wig on?
It's advisable to remove your wig before sleeping or showering:
- Sleeping: Wearing a wig to bed can cause tangling and reduce its lifespan.
- Showering: Water and steam can damage the wig's fibers and styling.
Removing your wig helps maintain its quality and longevity.
For more personalized advice or questions, feel free to contact us or book a consultation with our experienced team.
